Why does Minchat Chinuch not explain a stolen sukkah's invalidity through the principle of a mitzvah performed through a transgression?
Minchat Chinuch distinguishes an unconditional obligation, such as taking the lulav, from the sukkah obligation during the seven days, which arises when one wishes to eat. In his explanation, this conditional mitzvah is not invalidated on that particular basis. Excluding a stolen sukkah therefore requires the separate teaching from “לך,” rather than relying only on the principle of a mitzvah performed through a transgression.
Quote from the source«במצוה כזו אין לפסול משום מצהב"ע»
- Author
- מנחת חינוך
- Source
- להתוודע — להתוודע — sukkos lehisvada lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2