Why did selling honors for large Torah-study pledges provoke different reactions?
Rabbi Gedalyah opposed such sales because he feared that undertaking too many pages would lead to superficial study without understanding. Rabbi Yosef Shlomo Kahaneman, by contrast, introduced the sale of honors for hundreds or thousands of pages and encouraged students to gain clear knowledge of the entire Talmud. The text presents different approaches to quantitative study commitments.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ואיזו תועלת כבר יכולה לצמוח לו מלימוד שטחי?»
- Author
- רבי גדליה; רבי יוסף שלמה כהנמן
- Source
- קובץ גליונות — קובץ גליונות — sukkos koivetz gilyoines lashon kodesh 5787, p. 24