Is an etrog so large that it must be carried on the shoulder valid for the mitzvah?
Size alone does not invalidate an etrog: the text recounts Rabbi Akiva carrying an enormous etrog on his shoulder. The Mishnah Berurah explains that someone who has all four species may take the lulav first and the etrog afterward. The Yaavetz clarifies that Rabbi Akiva carried the etrog on his shoulder on the way to the study hall, but did not fulfill the mitzvah by carrying it that way.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«אם היה גדול כל שהוא, כשר.»
- Author
- המשנ"ב; היעב"ץ
- Source
- אשכול יוסף — אשכול יוסף — sukkos eshkol yosef lashon kodesh 1 5787, p. 4