Why could the laws forgotten after Moses’ death not be recovered or verified through prophecy?
In Rabbi Yosef Teomim’s explanation, “These are the commandments” rules out introducing commandments through prophecy, while “It is not in heaven” also rules out heavenly verification of a conclusion reached through Torah study. Consulting a prophet therefore could not replace recovering forgotten laws through reasoning. The author explains the request to consult Samuel as a desire to verify Othniel ben Kenaz’s conclusions. Under the other opinion discussed, no doubts remained after Othniel restored the laws, and the request to Phinehas belonged to an earlier stage.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«אלא על כרחך, כיון שלא החזירן אלא מכח פלפולו, לא רצו לסמוך עליו, ואמרו: נשאל אם כיון להלכה.»
- Author
- הג"ר יוסף תאומים
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — sukkos drushim kadmonim lashon kodesh 5787, p. 9