Why does the Tur explain the significance of Hoshana Rabbah through judgment concerning water rather than the completion of the Rosh Hashanah judgment?
The author compares two explanations: the completion of the Rosh Hashanah judgment and judgment concerning water. He examines an interpretation linking Yom Kippur and Hoshana Rabbah to the reckoning of the solar year, under which Israel’s judgment ends on Yom Kippur while Hoshana Rabbah concerns the nations. However, this encounters the Mishnah’s statement that all inhabitants of the world pass before God on Rosh Hashanah. The Tur’s explanation through judgment concerning water is therefore presented as avoiding this difficulty.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולכך הוצרך הטור לטעם שבחג נידונין על המים.»
- Author
- ר' שמחה כ"ץ רפאפורט
- Source
- דרושים קדמונים — דרושים קדמונים — sukkos drushim kadmonim lashon kodesh 5787, p. 7