Can a sacrifice, judicial punishment, or compensation replace repentance?
A sin offering or an administered judicial punishment does not bring atonement without repentance and verbal confession. Likewise, someone who injured another person or damaged their property does not gain atonement through payment alone: confession and a commitment never to repeat the act are required.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«ו ְכ ֵן כ ָּל מְחֻי ְ ּב ֵי מ ִיתו ֹת ב ֵּית ד ִּין וּמְחֻי ְ ּב ֵי מ ַל ְקו ֹת א ֵין מִת ְכ ַּפּ ֵר לָה ֶן ב ְ ּמ ִיתָת ָן או ֹ ב ִּלְק ִי ָ ּת ָן ע ַד שׁ ֶי ַ ּע ֲשוׂ ּ תּ ְשׁ וּב ָה ו ְיִת ְו ַד ּו ּ .»
- Author
- רמב"ם
- Source
- חתת פלוס — חתת פלוס, p. 36