Why did the Rosh question saying a blessing over immersion before a festival?
The article states that once the ashes of the red heifer disappeared, purification from corpse impurity was no longer possible. The Rosh therefore questioned Rabbi Saadia Gaon's instruction to recite a blessing over immersion before a festival, since that immersion cannot accomplish this purification. The article does not provide a final practical ruling.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולכן תמה הרא"ש על רס"ג למה הורה לברך על הטבילה לפני הרגל, כאשר אין בידינו להיטהר.»
- Author
- הרא"ש
- Source
- Shabbat Tish — Shabbat Tish, p. 3