How did Rabbi Yaakov defend the credibility of his account of his brother’s appointment?
Rabbi Yaakov reported that his father, the Noda BiYehuda, wanted his second son, Rabbi Shmuel, to succeed him. When his account was challenged, he argued that if he were inventing his father’s wishes for personal gain, he would have named himself. He compared this to the explanation of why Moshe was trusted concerning Aharon’s appointment: had Moshe fabricated it for his own benefit, he would have appointed himself High Priest.
Quote from the source«ׁשֶ כֵּ ן ִאלּ וּ ָרצָ ה לְ ׁשַ ֵקּ ר הָ יָ ה מְ מַ נֶּ ה ֶאת ַ צְ מוֹ לְ כֹהֵ ן גָּ דוֹ ל וְ לֹא ֶאת ָא ִחיו»
- Author
- רבי יעקב
- Source
- Shabbat Tish — Shabbat Tish — שבת טיש — Shemini 5784, p. 1
- Parsha
- Shemini