Why did David’s and Shaul’s repentance have different consequences for their kingship?
Sefer HaChaim explains the difference through the nature of the obligation. David violated a prohibition binding on everyone, whereas Shaul failed to fulfill the king’s duty concerning the destruction of Amalek, which no one could perform in his place. In this explanation, Shaul’s repentance therefore did not prevent the loss of his kingship; Divrei Shaul connects this distinction to the phrase “the people’s guilt.”
Quote from the source«אבל שאול חטא במצווה של המלך, מצוות מחיית עמלק, ואם הוא לא מחה, הרי אין מי שיכול לעשות את זה במקומו,»
- Author
- אחי המהר"ל ב"ספר החיים"; ה"דברי שאול"
- Source
- מדשן ביתך — [2796]מדשן ביתך ויקרא - זכור — Vayikra 5784, p. 16
- Parsha
- Vayikra