Is a chatat brought if someone realizes the violation before the act ends but can no longer stop it?
In R. Hirsch’s explanation, a chatat is brought only when the violation was unwitting from beginning to end. If someone remembers that it is Shabbat after throwing a stone from a private domain into a public one but before it lands, no chatat is brought. Awareness changes the case even though the action can no longer be stopped; sacrifices atone for specific categories of sin.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«If a Jew throws a rock not thinking it Shabbat, and remembers before it lands, there will be no chatat»
- Author
- R. Hirsch
- Source
- Torah Musings — Torah Musings — Musings - Vayikra 5784, p. 3
- Parsha
- Vayikra