What determines whether a synagogue may be sold to build a new one?
The Gemara distinguishes a village synagogue, which may be sold, from a city synagogue belonging to the wider public, which may not. Rishonim explain the prohibition through ownership by all Jews, donations from different places, or added sanctity from its many worshippers. Under the donation explanation, exclusively local funding permits a sale; some opinions also recognize communal leaders’ authority under certain conditions. More recent authorities consider the city-synagogue category inapplicable today, and the article also allows sale with the consent of a major rabbi whose authority everyone accepts.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Additionally, more recent poskim posit that the categorization of a “city shul” is no longer applicable in the present age.»
- Author
- Rabbi Hillel Raskin
- Source
- Brooklyn Torah Gazette — Brooklyn Torah Gazette — Kol Simcha Torah Gazette for Parshas Pekudei 5784, p. 27
- Parsha
- Pekudei