Can Tosafot’s reasoning imply that something permitted can be nullified in a forbidden mixture?
The author infers from Tosafot’s question that, in their view, something permitted can also be nullified in a forbidden mixture. They ask why an animal exempt from tithing is not nullified among animals subject to tithing; the author treats exemption and obligation here as analogous to permission and prohibition. He notes that a similar inference can be drawn from the cited discussion in Maharil’s responsa.
Quote from the source«דסבירא להו דגם היתיר באיסור — בטל»
- Author
- רבי יוסף ענגיל
- Source
- אברך — [1228]אברך ויקהל - שקלים — Vayak'hel 5784, p. 4
- Parsha
- Vayakhel