Does taking someone’s property against their will violate “Do not covet” if you pay for it?
Korban Chagigah presents two interpretations: one holds that the prohibition applies even when payment is made, while the other limits it to taking without payment. The author supports the first interpretation: people’s mistaken belief that payment removes the prohibition explains why they were initially not disqualified as witnesses under Torah law. When forcible taking became habitual, the Sages instituted their disqualification.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ולעולם דאמיתות הפסוק דאפילו בדמי עובר אלאו ד'לא תחמוד'»
- Author
- רבי יוסף ענגיל
- Source
- אברך — [1228]אברך ויקהל - שקלים — Vayak'hel 5784, p. 4
- Parsha
- Vayakhel