May someone take another person’s property without permission in order to return something better?
The discussion begins with the prohibition against stealing even with the intention of repaying double, then offers several explanations of taking a rib from the sleeping Adam. The Yaavetz distinguishes temporary distress from a case where the person is asleep and feels none, and also discusses assured repayment intended for the owner’s benefit. Yalkut HaGershuni, drawing on the Shach, considers immediately vesting ownership of a better replacement through a third party. These are distinct conditions discussed by the sources, rather than a general permission to take another’s property for an intended benefit.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«דע''פ האמת הכל של הקב''ה ולא שייך גזל ואינו מתחיל קושיא כלל»
- Author
- מעדני אשר; יעב״ץ; ילקוט הגרשוני; הש״ך
- Source
- למודי משה — למודי משה — Bereishit 5786, p. 19
- Parsha
- Bereishit