Why might Yitzchak have thought that both Yaakov and Esav would belong to the chosen nation?
Menachem Leibtag suggests that Yitzchak did not know in which generation the selection of a single son would end and could have expected both sons to continue Avraham’s family. Unlike Yitzchak and Yishmael, they were twins born to the same mother. Moreover, God Himself had previously chosen the heir, so Yitzchak had no basis for independently rejecting either son.
Quote from the source«Therefore, it is only logical for Yitzchak to assume that BOTH Yaakov and Esav will join the 'chosen family'.»
- Author
- Menachem Leibtag
- Source
- Parsha.net — Toldos63, p. 5
- Parsha
- Toldot