Should someone be denied Torah study because their character is not yet ideal?
According to the Chiddushei Harim, Rabban Gamaliel regretted rejecting students when he saw how Torah study transformed their inner lives. Those who had seemed superficial became sincere Torah scholars. Evaluating a student should therefore take account not only of who they are now, but also of who they may become through learning.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«He had not given these young men the opportunity to be exposed to Torah.»
- Author
- The Chiddushei Harim
- Source
- זכרון יעקב — זכרון יעקב, p. 2