May I leave food in a sous vide bath to keep it hot on Shabbos?
Rabbi Chaim Hillel Raskin explains that both shehiya, leaving food on a heat source, and hatmana, insulating food, must be considered. Adding raw meat immediately before Shabbos or sufficient prior cooking could address shehiya; the Alter Rebbe permits half-cooked food while allowing for the stricter view requiring it to be fully cooked to the point that further heating harms it. However, a bag completely surrounded by continuously heated water is considered insulated in a heat-increasing substance, which is prohibited even before Shabbos. Food therefore may not be kept hot this way unless the heater is set to turn off before Shabbos and only the previously heated water keeps it warm. The author also infers from the halachic authorities that this arrangement should not be prepared on Friday even for food after Shabbos; his note advises consulting a rabbi in pressing circumstances.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«This prohibition is stricter and none of the leniencies of shehiya apply.»
- Author
- Rabbi Chaim Hillel Raskin
- Source
- The Weekly Farbrengen — 547 - The Foundation of the Home (I), p. 2