How should we view loud prayer and vigorous movement during prayer?
Rabbi Chaim of Brisk criticized excessive shouting and movement: if the High Priest prayed that way, the bells on his robe would have been unnecessary. The Baal Shem Tov, by contrast, explained his disciples’ movements through the image of a drowning person waving his arms and calling for help. In that case, the movements express an inner need to escape distress and should not be mocked.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«לשם מה היה הכהן הגדול זקוק לפעמונים שנקבעו בשולי מעילו?»
- Author
- רבי חיים מבריסק; הבעל שם טוב
- Source
- מדשן ביתך — [2796]מדשן ביתך תצוה — Tetzaveh 5784, p. 6
- Parsha
- Tetzaveh