What underlies the disagreement about placing the second Tablets above the broken first Tablets?
In Malbim’s reading, the disagreement concerns whether Tablets made by Moshe may rest on the broken Tablets made by God. The Yerushalmi’s approach preserves the first Tablets’ greater sanctity and places them separately or alongside the second set. The Bavli, on this explanation, holds that their writing returned to Heaven when they broke, leaving their sanctity absent or diminished enough to permit placing them underneath the second Tablets.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«Enough to be acceptably placed under the other Tablets.»
- Author
- Malbim
- Source
- Torah Musings — Torah Musings — Musings - Terumah 5784, p. 4
- Parsha
- Terumah