Must a cleaner pay for a dish she accidentally broke while washing it?
Chavos Yair writes that the cleaner is ordinarily liable as a paid guardian, but is exempt when the prevailing practice is that almost no one demands compensation for such damage. The role of custom is explained differently: some see it as applying to damages, while others connect it to employment and guardianship terms that custom can establish. Another cited view questions disregarding even a small minority of particular employers. According to that view, if such an employer still holds the wages, the employer cannot be compelled to pay them in full without deducting the dish’s value.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«This seemingly extends the concept of minhag hamedinah to liabilities that are not contractual, such as damages.»
- Author
- Harav Chaim Kohn
- Source
- Business Weekly — Business Weekly — aBizWeekly-English — Terumah 5784, p. 2
- Parsha
- Terumah