Why were the tribal names carved into the Ephod stones while the Choshen stones had to remain whole?
Rav Aharon David Willner explains that the shoulder stones represent practical responsibility for the people’s needs: such help requires resources and cannot always reach everyone. Their carving could therefore remove part of the stone. The stones over the heart represent concern for every person without exception, so they had to remain whole; their names were formed using the shamir.
Quote from the source«The concern of every person in Yisroel had to be borne by the Kohen Gadol.»
- Author
- Rav Aharon David Willner
- Source
- Limuday Moshe — Limuday Moshe — 207- Terumah B5 5784, p. 7
- Parsha
- Terumah