May a judge state the opposite of his view to induce his colleagues to reach the right decision?
The responsa Zayit Ra'anan reject this tactic even when a judge expects his colleagues to oppose him and thereby adopt his actual view. He must honestly state and explain his position. If they disagree, he is not at fault for having spoken truthfully.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«רק אמור את דעתך האמיתית, וברר אף לחבריך שהאמת כדבריך.»
- Author
- Редакция «מדשן ביתך»
- Source
- מדשן ביתך — [2796]מדשן ביתך משפטים — Mishpatim 5784, p. 22
- Parsha
- Mishpatim