Is someone who borrows a book to study Torah liable for its accidental loss?
The text presents differing opinions: the Ran exempts the borrower from borrower-level liability because the lender also benefits from performing a mitzvah, while Ketzot HaChoshen bases exemption on the principle that mitzvot were not given for enjoyment. Netivot HaMishpat holds the book's borrower liable for unavoidable events and limits the cited ruling of the Ran to a particular case involving collateral. Machaneh Ephraim also requires payment, pointing to the benefit of using for free a book that could have been rented.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«והנתיה"מ ז"ל סובר דשאל ספר חייב באונסין»
- Author
- הר"ן; קצוה"ח; נתיה"מ; מחנה אפרים
- Source
- משפטים — משפטים — Mishpatim 5784, p. 3
- Parsha
- Mishpatim