Why protest cruelty if the protest will not change the outcome?
The Brisker Rav explains that Iyov's silence during the discussion of the decree to drown Jewish babies was unacceptable even if he could not affect the decision. A person cries out in pain even when crying does not remove its cause. The children's suffering therefore called for an outcry regardless of its practical effect.
Quote from the source«The Brisker Rav 16 asks what harm was done by abstaining and answers that screaming was necessary.»
- Author
- Brisker Rav
- Source
- Parsha B'Iyun — Parsha B'Iyun — papers — Yisro 5784, p. 5
- Parsha
- Yitro