Why is an oath based on one witness needed if we assume that someone who denies an entire claim must also swear?
Yad Yehuda explains that even on this assumption, an oath for complete denial would require a definite claim of two silver units, as with partial admission. If the claimant is certain about only one unit and only the witness knows about the second, the ordinary basis for an oath is absent, but the witness’s testimony creates the obligation. If the defendant pays and then sues to recover the money, the recipient can deny owing one unit with certainty and plead uncertainty about the other; there is no denial of two units, so the proposed workaround based on inability to swear fails.
Quote from the source«דאי ימא דגם כופר הכל מחויב שבועה בודאי לא גרע מן מודה במקצת דצריך טעה שתי כסף»
- Author
- רבי יהודה לייבש הכהן לאנדא
- Source
- הילולא דצדקיא — הילולא דצדקיא — Yisro 5784, p. 6
- Parsha
- Yitro