Does a successful outcome prove that my decision was wise?
In the story, a shopkeeper refused to sell part of his stock at a reduced price while a fire threatened his shop, then took pride in his judgment when the shop survived. Rabbi Chaim Brisker explained that, given the natural course of events, the decision was unwise and the offer should have been accepted. He attributed the preservation of the property to God's decree: a person may retain money despite acting foolishly, so success does not justify pride.
Quote from the source«ר' חיים בריסקער האט געזאגט אז באמת וואס דער מענטש האט געטוהן איז נישט געווען קלוג.»
- Author
- ר' חיים בריסקער
- Source
- געוואלדיגע רעיונות — געוואלדיגע רעיונות — Beshalach 5784, p. 2
- Parsha
- Beshalach