Did donations have to be returned when the letter canceling a hardship was written before the righteous man prayed?
In the reported case, Rabbi Shlomo Kluger ruled that the money collected to redeem captives did not have to be returned. He explained that although the letter had been prepared earlier, it reached its destination only after the righteous man prayed. God could prepare deliverance in anticipation of the future donation and prayer; the rabbi supported this from the blessing of Oved-Edom’s household for hosting the Ark.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כי אמנם הקב"ה הקדים רפואה למכה אולם עדיין היה חסר להם את תפילת הצדיק»
- Author
- רבי שלמה קלוגר
- Source
- גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — באר הפרשה - שמות תשפ''ד A4 — Shemos 5784, p. 8
- Parsha
- Shemot