May Hanukkah candles be lit in an open glass case and then protected from the wind by closing its door?
The text raises the concern that candles exposed to an ordinary wind at the moment of lighting may not have been lit properly. Grounds for permitting the practice include shielding the candles with one's body and Har Tzvi's view that the obligation is fulfilled if they do not actually go out. Rabbi Chaim Kanievsky takes the intention to close the door immediately into account, whereas the discussion infers from the Chazon Ish that intention alone is insufficient. It also cites Maharil Diskin's practice of lighting with protection already in place.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כך שכבר בעת ההדלקה הנרות מוגנות מפני הרוח.»
- Author
- Редакция «אגישמאקע ווארט»
- Source
- אגישמאקע ווארט — אגישמאקע ווארט — Mikeitz 5784, p. 27
- Parsha
- Miketz