Would Yosef have been punished if he had asked the cupbearer to remember him only once?
Rav Shimon Shkop suggested that the punishment would have been one year instead of two. Rav Chaim of Brisk replied that there would have been no punishment: one request fulfilled the obligation of effort, whereas repetition, in his explanation, revealed reliance on the request itself and changed the assessment of both requests.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«כי פעם אחת היה עליו לומר 'זכרתני' מחובת ה'השתדלות'»
- Author
- הגר"ח מבריסק; הגר"ש שקאפ
- Source
- גליון באר הפרשה — גליון באר הפרשה — באר הפרשה - מקץ תשפ''ד A4 — Mikeitz 5784, p. 8
- Parsha
- Miketz