Why was the earth punished for departing from God’s command only after Adam sinned?
The earth has no free choice, so its punishment is explained as a lesson to humanity about the consequences of sin. Rabbeinu Chananel similarly explains the punishment of angels. Before Adam’s sin, such a lesson did not yet serve its purpose; after eating from the Tree of Knowledge, humanity gained awareness of reward and punishment, and the evil inclination entered them. The earth was therefore punished together with humanity so that people could learn from its example.
Quote from the source«ולכן רק עתה כשנענש האדם נפקדה האדמה.»
- Author
- משאת המלך
- Source
- פרדס לשולחן שבת — פרדס לשולחן שבת — pardas lashulchan hashabbos 144358 — Bereishis 5787, p. 1
- Parsha
- Bereishit