Should one circle the bimah or wave the separate willow branches on Hoshana Rabbah?
Although an opinion supports making circuits with the willows designated for beating, the widespread Sephardi and Ashkenazi custom is not to circle with them. The kabbalistic explanation separates the lulav, associated with kindness, from these willows, associated with judgment. In the sequence described, after the circuits with the four species and Musaf, the willows are taken for beating against the ground; Ashkenazim also wave them and recite supplications for water before beating them.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ובני אשכנז נוהגים אף לנענען ולומר כשהם בידו תחנונים על המים ואח״כ חובטים את הערבה.»
- Author
- הרב משה חיים חנונו
- Source
- שו"ת בהלכה לשולחן שבת — שו"ת בהלכה לשולחן שבת — sukkos shu t behalacha lashon kodesh 5787, p. 2