How can the same etrog be valid for one person and invalid for another?
The text gives five cases: the ownership requirement allows the owner to fulfill the mitzvah with an etrog, but someone borrowing it cannot. A stolen etrog is invalid for the thief even after its owner has given up hope of recovering it, but it may be valid for another person. An etrog missing a piece is described as invalid on the second festival day for a Diaspora resident but valid for a resident of the Land of Israel. The maximum size depends on a person's ability to hold it, so a large etrog may be valid for a strong person and invalid for a weak person. A light-black etrog is valid in a place where such etrogim normally grow; the text cites Shulchan Aruch 648:17 for this case.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«What are five ways to have אתרג כשרfor one person but not for another?»
- Author
- Редакция «Parsha Challenge»
- Source
- Parsha Challenge — sukkos parsha challenge - english english 5787, p. 2