Is there a difference between two festival statuses that always coincide and Yom Tov falling on Shabbat only occasionally?
The author proposes distinguishing these cases. When a rabbinic festival always coincides with an existing festival, one can argue that additional reinforcement was unnecessary from the outset. Yom Tov, however, requires an independent muktzeh enactment when it falls on a weekday, so that enactment may remain in force through lo plug when it coincides with Shabbat. This is a proposed distinction rather than a definitive ruling.
Quote from the source«אבל ביום טוב שאין קביעות ליום טוב שיחול בשבת, אפשר שאומרים סברת לא פלוג ואוסרים אף אם אירע שחל בשבת.»
- Author
- רבי יעקב גרינוולד
- Source
- אוצר באר יעקב — אוצר באר יעקב — sukkos otzar beer yakov lashon kodesh 5787, p. 3