What underlies Ramban’s view that Hallel accompanying these festival commandments is required by Torah law?
Ramban cites the Sages’ astonishment: could Israel offer the Pesach sacrifice and take the lulav without a song of praise? The author explains that when a commandment’s very substance is joy and praise of God, verbal Hallel naturally belongs with it. This reasoning applies specifically to such commandments, rather than to every performance of a commandment.
Quote from the source«הרמב"ן הוכיח ממימרא זו, שהלל באכילת פסחים ובנטילת לולב הוא מדאורייתא»
- Author
- רבי לייב מינצברג
- Source
- אוצרות בן מלך — אוצרות בן מלך — sukkos oitzrois ben melech lashon kodesh 5787, p. 7