According to Gotfryd, what distinguishes a person from a talking doll?
Gotfryd distinguishes producing sounds from conscious speech: a doll’s sounds mean something to the listener, but not to the doll itself. He points to human experience, awareness, and self-consciousness as things the battery analogy does not explain. He also does not deny souls to animals, plants, or even inanimate objects.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«The noises the doll makes mean nothing to it.»
- Author
- Aryeh Gotfryd
- Source
- Beis Moshiach - English — 745, p. 34