I bought a used electric frying pan that the seller represented as working, but it does not work. Can I demand a refund if he offers to repair it?
In the case discussed, the buyer could easily have tested the appliance but did not, so the author does not recognize an ordinary claim of mistaken purchase; however, the seller's response about its condition made the purchase contingent on the appliance working. According to the Magen Avrohom, the buyer may refuse repairs because the condition was not fulfilled; the Mekor Chaim also permits refusal because the appliance received was unusable. Other authorities cited allow the seller to uphold the sale by repairing it. Since the seller already holds the money and the matter is disputed, the buyer cannot compel a refund if the seller offers to replace the defective part.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
This answer was given to a specific person, not as a general rule.
Quote from the source«There are differing opinions if the seller can refuse to return your money by offering to replace the defective part.»
- Author
- Rabbi Yosef Fleischman
- Source
- Torah & Horaah — Torah & Horaah — Fleischman-Ha'azinu - Bought a used appliance that does not work-Part 2 5784, p. 4
- Parsha
- Haazinu