How does the Chatam Sofer distinguish sin driven by desire from sin driven by deliberate opposition to Torah?
The Chatam Sofer proposes examining a person’s conduct when bodily desires weaken with age. If wrongdoing stops as those desires fade, this indicates that desire was its driving force; if wrongdoing instead increases, he attributes it to deliberate opposition to Torah. He uses this distinction to interpret the verse about the evil inclination of the heart and explain why such conduct cannot be attributed to the earth from which the person was formed.
Quote from the source«מזה מוכח שרק כח שכלו להתחכם נגד התורה זה גרם לו שחטא.»
- Author
- החתם סופר
- Source
- היכל החתם סופר — היכל החתם סופר — Noach 5787, p. 5
- Parsha
- Noach