Is it permissible to seek guidance for action in a sacred text opened at random?
The article cites the Rama’s permission to ask a child for a learned verse and act accordingly, and the Shach’s extension of this to opening a book. It also quotes the Rambam’s prohibition against making action depend on self-appointed omens, alongside objections by the Raavad, Kesef Mishna, and Ran. As presented in the article, the Kesef Mishna permits a sign meaningfully connected to the matter itself, such as watering the camels as a test of Rivka’s suitability. The author concludes that the permissive opinions, rather than the Rambam, are followed in this case.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«In short: From all the above we see that in this instance, we do not rule like the Rambam.»
- Author
- Rabbi Gershon Avtzon
- Source
- Beis Moshiach - English — 819, p. 28