Why are there different arguments about lighting a Shabbat candle away from the place of the meal?
Mahari Weil prohibits such lighting because an observer might think the candle was lit for an ordinary need, comparing it to a Hanukkah light. The author challenges this comparison: Hanukkah lighting publicizes the miracle, making the observer’s perception essential, whereas Shabbat lighting does not depend on that perception. A concern that an observer might suspect failure to fulfill the mitzvah requires a separate justification.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«ומה שאין כן שבת לאו ברואים תליא מילתא, ומה לנו בכך דהרואה יאמר כו'.»
- Author
- רבינו [?], גליוני הש״ס
- Source
- אברך — אברך — Pinchas 5786, p. 2
- Parsha
- Pinchas