Why did the Chatam Sofer and the author of Shoel Umeshiv object to celebrating a righteous person's death?
They pointed out that the deaths of righteous people are generally marked by fasting, and therefore questioned celebrating Rashbi's death. The author of Shoel Umeshiv explained that departure may bring joy to the righteous person who has found rest, while those left behind experience loss.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«היכן מצינו לעשות יום מועד ביום סילוק הצדיק?»
- Author
- החתם סופר; בעל ה"שואל ומשיב"
- Source
- ליקוטי שמואל — ליקוטי שמואל, p. 2