Why is it forbidden to deprive a fisherman of an expected catch if the fish are ownerless?
According to Rabbeinu Tam, the prohibition of oni hamehapeich bacharoro applies, for example, when someone is about to obtain a job, but does not prohibit obtaining a free, ownerless item ahead of another person. Tosafos explains that the fisherman's case is different because his livelihood is involved. It is therefore forbidden to deprive him of his expected catch, even a single fish, although the fish are still ownerless.
A practical halachic question: the final ruling is for your rabbi.
Quote from the source«Tosafos answers that the reason even Rabbeinu Tam agrees that such fishing is prohibited is because it is the fisherman's livelihood.»
- Author
- Tosafos
- Source
- Torah & Horaah — Torah & Horaah — Fleischman-Re'ei - Former employee opens a rival firm and woos customers of his previous firm-Part 1 — Re'eh 5783, p. 3
- Parsha
- Re'eh