Is the mitzvah of charity fulfilled if the poor person refuses the gift?
The footnote presents different approaches. The Rashba and Rabbi Yosef ben Plat explain the absence of a blessing over charity by the possibility that the poor person will refuse it, which the discussion connects to whether the mitzvah is fulfilled. Beit Hillel explicitly considers the mitzvah fulfilled even when the recipient refuses; no final ruling is given here.
The source brings differing opinions.
Quote from the source«דכשהעני לא רצה לקבל יצא מצות צדקה,»
- Author
- הרשב"א; ר"י בן פלט; בית הלל
- Source
- התקשרות — התקשרות — hrus-Re'eh-imp 5783, p. 11
- Parsha
- Re'eh