Why is the case of Tzelafchad’s daughters considered a rebuke to Moshe when he also did not know the answer about Pesach Sheini?
Rabbeinu Bachye explains that allowing a daughter to inherit is straightforward and reasonable, and is recognized even by nations whose laws rest on human reasoning alone. Not knowing this ruling is therefore understood as a consequence of Moshe’s statement about bringing difficult cases to him. Pesach Sheini, by contrast, could not be inferred from the usual rules: as the article explains, the Torah provides no other precedent for such an opportunity, and someone prevented from fulfilling an obligation by circumstances beyond their control is generally exempt.
Quote from the source«There is no precedent for such an idea anywhere else in the Torah.»
- Author
- Rabbeinu Bachye; Rabbi Immanuel Bernstein
- Source
- Meshech Chochma — Meshech Chochma — shelmikra devarim 2023 — Devorim 5783, p. 4
- Parsha
- Devarim